Latest Reviews 
Latest News 
Latest Blogs 
Latest Games 
Latest Features 
iPods deliver a lousy taste in music

By Damian Francis, 2/21/2008 3:49:35 PM

An iPod with a 160GB hard drive! Fan-bloody-tastic. Or is it? Maybe it’s just me but from what I gather from most of my iPod owning friends, the majority of the music they have on their iPod is crap.



I was at a mates place last Saturday. She just bought a new iMac. She’s also got a black iPod. Being the hardcore tech journalist that I am, I walked up to have a look. I’ve seen an iMac before, I’ve seen a black iPod before, but no matter how many times I see them, there’s something that still inspires a bit of awe, especially from a device like an iPod that has a whopping 160GB hard drive in it.

Sitting at her desk I started to flick through the hundreds of albums she has in her digital music collection (but still only used 25GB of space). She has a great taste in music, don’t get me wrong, but every now and then would come the statement from behind my back, “that’s crap, I don’t even know why I have it on there.”

And there’s the problem. When MP3 players were just becoming popular, and their capacities were at the 10GB stage, we were somewhat more cautious about the music we put on them, and indeed, the music we bought. But with the influx of extremely large capacity players, not just from Apple, but from the likes of Creative, Archos and others, it seems that we’re now just filling them for the sake of filling them.

What was once a collection of music your heart would beat to has now become just a random collection of whatever was lying around on your bedroom floor, your mates lounge room, your cousins computer or on internet torrent sites (not that anyone at gadget zone condones the downloading of illegal music).

Sadly, I myself am an iPod owner and collector of digital music I don’t even like. I didn’t need to buy an iPod with that much storage, but I did. Why? Because it looks damn good and it’s hard to say “no” to 160GB of storage. I justified it by saying I can use it as a hard drive as well, and that it’s great value (which it is).
Page 1 of 2
 |<  < 1 - 2  >  >| 





Comments
ivan
yeah thats true, i have the same problem with my mediacentre, with so much harddrive space, I tend to keep all kinds of TV shows and movies that I know i'm never gonna watch...
2/22/2008 9:11:31 AM

Richard Sossen
If I could have a terabyte MP3 player filled with the history of music on it I would. THis is not for wow factor but for educational, inspirational and recreational purposes! I guess it depends on how eclectic your tast in music is and how far it spans. If you can have it...why not?
2/22/2008 1:51:12 PM

Jenneth Orantia
I'm of the opinion that if you have too much music to choose from, you'll actually spend more time trying to decide what you want to listen to than actually listening to music. Back when CD Walkmans were in, you usually only had the one CD that was in the player. 10-15 songs, you'd just press play, sit back, and enjoy the album. Now that you can have hundreds of albums to choose from, you're spoilt for choice, and it gets harder and harder to decide what you want to hear. That's my two cents, anyway :P
2/22/2008 5:41:57 PM

Damian Francis
And do you then sit back, after you've finally chosen something to listen to and get bored mid track purely because there is another track on your iPod you think you would rather listen to. So you change, and then get bored of that mid track.
2/22/2008 7:53:17 PM

KitKat
This IPOD is the size of my Ipaq and for a read only device, that's a little too chunky for my liking. For something that size, I prefer my PDA and it does alot more too. I went for the 3G Nano. It only has 8gb of space, but that's enough to store more than I really need on the go.... and it's tiny.
2/23/2008 12:54:47 AM

zoidfromthevoid
This may seem a dumb question, but with all that space, does itunes allow you to store uncompressed files? WAV for instance?
2/23/2008 10:14:34 PM

Luna
Yes, it does. Using iTunes, it imports using AAC, AIFF (uncompressed), MP3 and WAV encoders, plus it can also import using Apples own lossless encoder.
2/24/2008 1:24:59 AM

zoidfromthevoid
I think I could just about fit my entire CD collection (uncompressed) on the 160 gb iPod, then!!!
2/27/2008 6:26:09 PM

bunnybash
yeah this is why subscription music is going to take off and why the Zune ecosystem works so well, you don't need to buy the music that is crap! hopefully the bigger hard drives will allow users to start ripping their music at decent bit rates now instead of crappy low ones!!
6/6/2008 4:46:34 PM

Leave a Comment
Name:

Your url:
Comments:

Enter security code: